Today we're turning the tables - instead of prompts and writing advice from me, I'd love your feedback. Big day yesterday - all sorts of fun planned in London, meeting with lovely new agent, general excitement. Unfortunately just as I'm about to board the train, pilot gets a call. 'Ah, he says - crewing just called. I'm off to the Dominican Republic for six days'. Small matter of two little children. Frantic calls on the way to London - imagine having to cancel at this point to get home to do the school run ... Luckily our saintly babysitter stepped in and saved the day and I rushed home afterwards for bathtime.Anyway - just another domestic disaster we're all used to juggling, right? The meeting was great - it's all happening, which is thrilling. The book's going out for a sneak preview, and the main submissions will be in January. But another title change is being considered on the first book - which is where I'd love your help. Here's the blurb:
Maya Dumas discovers over the course of a summer that 'love and loss come in equal measure', as she returns to her childhood home to paint her estranged mother’s portrait. When her mother reveals that not only is she dying, but that she is being blackmailed, secrets about her celebrated American war photographer father emerge. Maya finds her life changing forever as she is drawn back into the world of her peripatetic childhood, and rediscovers a secret love she thought she would never find again.
All you regular readers will know my ideas about 'method' writing - really immersing yourself in the characters, casting/visualising the book like a film. So you can picture it - Maya 'is' Emmanuelle Beart, her mother I've always seen as Catherine Deneuve, George her godfather 'is' Terence Stamp - it's set in New York, France, and the wild coast of Devon where I grew up. Hopefully you get the idea? One friend who read the samples said 'this isn't a book it's a French film'.
The title is: 'All the Lovely Ruined Things'. (Ted Hughes' original line was 'All, all the ruined lovely things' - but I rather feel things can be lovely and beautiful because or in spite of the fact life/time has 'ruined' them). The French title is 'Toutes Belles Choses Ruinees'. The problem the agency has is 'Ruined' - in the current economic climate is 'Ruined' too depressing? Do people want something ... cheerier? I love it, but can see their point - at the end of the day you want people to be intrigued, and buy the book.
They've suggested I think about alternative titles. The one I've come up with is 'The Secret Place' - as in the secret place in everyone's heart, and the literal secret place that holds all the answers to their family's secrets.
So - you're walking into Waterstone's, Borders, Barnes & Noble, Kinokuniya, John Sandoe or your lovely local independent bookstore. There are two books in front of you 'All the Lovely Ruined Things' and 'The Secret Place' - which would you go for?
I would genuinely love your thoughts - anyone who reads today, all you lovely subscribers - please click on the little grey 'comments' link at the end of this post. Also (oh this is scary ...) The only people who have read samples are my agents and a couple of brutally honest writer friends. But it's Christmas, the book is being launched in a few weeks ... anyone who would like a sneak preview, drop me an email via the 'profile' page and I'll send you a little early Christmas reading to say thank you for the fun we've all had over the last few months.
TODAY'S PROMPT: End of term today - will much writing be done? Go, eat, drink, be merry - and buy books for Christmas.
UPDATE: Thank you all for the wonderful comments coming in on the blog, by email and on Facebook. Some of my favourite suggestions for alternative titles include: 'Sex & War' and 'Recession Sucks: Get Over It'. That 'The Secret Place' is also a kindergarten euphemism for bottoms in the US adds a whole new element to things ...

14 comments:
Here's what I think: All the Lovely Ruined things is WAY more memorable than"The Secret Place".
It poses questions- why are the lovely things ruined? What are the lovely things? It sets up an idea that there is going to be an element of tragedy (ruination) and intrigue. It sets up an idea of something that was once wonderful (the love) that is now irretrievably broken (the loss).
The Secret Place....hmmm not feeling it so much- sounds a little more run of the mill and (hoping to God you don't plump for it and I end up feeling bad about saying this) a little Catherine Cookson??? No disrespect to the great lady (as you know I read most of her stuff whilst staying over at my gran's house) but I'm guessing Cookson is not your main influence!
No matter what the title- I will buy your book Kate. No doubt about that. It sounds fantastic.
I want to ask you more questions about your meeting with agent but think I'll email you. Any top tips? Any questions you are glad you asked and would like to pass on to a green author just about to sign on the dotted line with an agent??? Hmmm?
Oh this is exciting! Good for you!!
I'd buy the 'Ruined' title. 'The Secret Place', I'm sure, has been used before. I like the word 'ruined' - it has more connotations..'Mother's ruin' etc...
'The Secret Place' sounds like a Black Lace book.. it's not intriguing enough.
I'm really chuffed for you though :o)
Sxx
I would TOTALLY buy the Ruined title. It appeals to me much more than the secret place. (That's what we call "you know what" in kindergarten when I am telling the kids not to show anyone their secret place...")
Missy, thank you - look forward to signing a copy for you!
Scarlet - Mother's ruin, yes there is plenty of that in the book too
Vodka Mom - LOL! It might attract a whole new readership!
I agree that The Secret Place has been done. The other title is better. I'd love to read it too, although I have a few other novels I'm reading for people and a show to... heck, I'd like to read your book one way or another.
Marta - thank you. I'll mail you a couple of chapters. Good luck with the show.
I don't like Secret Place at all. It's bland.
The Ruined one is intriguing. I like the contradiction of lovely and ruined. It brings up all sorts of connotations and images in the mind.
Besides, out of the ruins, a new world is born.
I would love to read a sample. Do you have my email?
Sure do Rowena - thank you! Love to hear what you think.
Thumbs down on The Secret Place from this corner. I agree that it is too simple and mundane. I don’t know your book, but I would be drawn to 'All the Lovely Ruined Things' a whole lot faster than The Secret Place.
Can’t believe that you are getting so close to fulfilling your dream, Kate. Can’t think of any one more deserving than you, right off the bat. Other than myself, of course. I’ll order your novel through a Norwegian outlet, thereby establishing a beachhead for you here in the frozen North.
Go, Kate, go!
Son, thank you for the Norwegian vote. And thanks for your vote of confidence - here's to a great year for us all.
I agree - The Secret Place sounds very generic. The Ruined Lovely Secret Place would be better... or the Lovely Secret Ruined Place, or the Secret Lovely Ruined...
Whatever you do, don't pick "A place for everything, and everything in their secret ruined lovely places." It's simply too long. :)
On a slightly more serious note, I do like All The Lovely Ruined Things. I should admit it reminds me a bit of Dirty Pretty Things, which is the name of a movie I did not see and is also the name of a band I've never heard (from London, I believe). That's not a bad thing - but it immediately came to mind when I read Lovely/Ruined so close together.
I'm with the Lovely Ruined Things. I could imagine the art cover to go with it. Secret Plac is too close to The Secret History and probably a lot of other titles.
I am hoping to catch up on reading Burning Lines. I only go to post 71 last week before my headache set in. It's addicting.
I'd love to read a sample and am looking forward to buying your book.
I agree with above, 'Lovely Ruined Things' definitely
and HUGE congratulations on all your success
( :
Dan - I don't know 'A Place for Everything ...' might just be memorable as the longest title EVER!
Pseudo - thank you, samples on the way this morning to you. I'm lost with BL too! Had a couple of days off writing a piece for the Times and now I'm reeling - if you look through JES has compiled the whole thing into one easy to read entry.
Megan - thank you! Let's hope 2009 will be a great year for all of us.
Post a Comment